Is Eli Manning a first-ballot Hall of Famer? That’s not a simple question for the Pro Football Hall of Fame selection committee, which has to decide if the two-time Super Bowl MVP is worthy of first-time entry into Canton.

The case is a bit complicated for the two-time Super Bowl MVP, who has a .500 career record as a starter and was a Pro Bowler in just four of his 16 seasons.

Unfortunately for Manning, his candidacy isn’t a slam dunk. His detractors will point to his .500 career record in regular-season games, a faulty argument given that wins and losses aren’t necessarily all on one man’s shoulders.